Posts tagged ‘Health Care Reform’
So, I was at a Town Hall meeting …
Congressman Joe Courtney hosted a Town Hall meeting on Thursday (August 6th) to discuss health care reform. This is the third such meeting I’ve been at since mid July. The first two were sparsely attended and extremely civil. People listened, had questions, and told their own stories about problems and concerns regarding health care coverage. Last week’s meeting was entirely different. How?
- The room was packed. Standing room only. Hundreds of people in attendance, in the most out of the way area in CT on a summer night!
- The atmosphere was heated, literally and figuratively.
- People in opposition to health care reform had signs and repeated points. Suddenly there was talk of forced euthanasia, the Constitution, and limits on care for “retarded children” and older people. None of this was mentioned at the earlier meetings just a few weeks ago.
- When one woman ( a veteran) spoke about the problems getting health care coverage for her special-needs child she was shouted down with the question: “Why don’t you move?” When she asked back, “where is your compassion, my husband and I both served this country and have done everything right,” she was greeted with hoots.
- When a local farmer spoke about the loss of her family farm and cows and her brother’s chronic illness, she was told to hurry up and sit down.
- When a woman with cancer told about not being able to get a needed study covered by her private insurance, someone yelled out, “Why don’t you just switch plans?” As she had explained, she said, “I can’t, I have a pre-existing condition!” “Awww,” said a group seated together in the crowd, feigning sympathy.
Now I am reading about these same points being made and attitudes reflected in similar atmoshpheres throughout the country.
While many people did come to listen and learn, too many did not. Of course this was organized. It’s the only explanation for the dramatic difference between the meetings before and after the Congressional Recess and for the repeated talking points and style. Unfortunately, it appears to be aimed at intimidating, not at community building, discourse, or learning. While Congressman Courtney was prepared, respectful and even-tempered throughout, few people could have heard and too many people left scared and sad. What a shame.
For the health of our country, we need to reform. We need to back away from this noise soon, before someone gets hurt.
Oh – and we need health care reform with a true public option. It’s the only way to get coverage for everyone at a price taxpayers can afford.
Medicare, We Hardly Know Ya
44 years ago Medicare was enacted into law. All of today’s dire warnings about a public health option – socialism and government barring the doctor’s door – were made in opposition to Medicare. Despite such opposition from “conservative,” leaders, including Senator Bob Dole, Medicare passed.
Before Medicare, 50% of everyone 65 or older had NO health insurance. Now, as a result of Medicare, almost all older people are insured. Medicare, which is national, government-run health insurance, succeeded in insuring older people where private insurance failed. And, until the Bush Administration privatized Medicare with the extraordinarily subsidized private “Medicare Advantage” and Part D plans, Medicare was remarkably cost-effective too. It’s private Medicare, not the traditional, public program, that’s bleeding taxpayers of billions of dollars.
Medicare has been a success, fiscally and morally. It took on the job of insuring health coverage and care to people that private insurance had abandoned. Since 2003, on the other hand, private Medicare plans have cost us all tens of billions of dollars that went to support the private insurance industry, not to providing health care. In addition, private Medicare plans have too often engaged in marketing abuses and restrictive coverage practices.
As Paul Krugman recognizes in today’s New York Times, people with Medicare love it. They do not want government to fool around with the traditional program. Ironically, these are sometimes the same people who worry that a public health care option will cause long waits for health care and government invasions into their private medical decisions. They, and their family members, (which accounts for pretty much all of us), forget that the traditional Medicare program is a public health insurance option.
Hello, America, meet Medicare: Our 44 year-old public health insurance option that provides care to all its enrollees, anywhere in the country, and that has provided health and economic security for millions of older people, people with disabilities, and their families.
Happy anniversary, Medicare. Thank you for showing us what a true public insurance program can offer.
Yes, Virginia, A Public Health Insurance Option Will Save Money and Provide Access To Good Care
Once again, probing, independent minds have concluded that a public health option will save money and provide stable access to health care. A new Commonwealth Fund report finds “A public insurance plan can help drive new efficiencies in the system that will produce large cost reductions. Without a public plan, much of those potential savings will be lost,”
With a public option and a standard set of benefits across all private and public plans, everyone will be better able to access coverage they can understand, at a price taxpayers can afford.
We get it. We need health care reform. We need a public option. We don’t believe in fairy tales. Tell Congress!
Is Senator Lieberman Kidding?
I am appalled that Senator Lieberman has announced his opposition to a public plan in health care reform. Can he really believe a PUBLIC option can’t be afforded after our experience with Medicare and Medicare private plans! As Medicare has shown, private plans are what we can’t afford. Study after study shows that Medicare, our only experience with a national health insurance, is spending about 14% more in private plans than it would pay for the same care in the traditional, public Medicare program. The extra payments to private Medicare plans equal about $15 billion a year! Come on – if we really are worrying about cost, a public plan is what we CAN afford. It’s private insurance that’s killing Medicare and that will bankrupt health care “reform”.
Mr. President: Listen to Your Doctor!
The (President’s) doctor orders Medicare for all. He’s right. If conventional wisdom is correct, and a single payer system is not “on the table,” surely the President and reform leaders must at least insist on a public health insurance option.
If the goal of health care reform is to provide coverage for all as cost-effectively as possible, a public health insurance plan MUST be included in any health care reform package. We can’t afford to be scared again by dire warnings about Big Government. Big Insurance costs a lot more than a public program and it helps people get health coverage a lot less. Ask anyone who really knows about the public Medicare program and private Medicare plans.
Support a true public health insurance option! It’s best for people who need health care and most cost-effective for taxpayers. Isn’t that what the President and his doctor ordered?
From the Desk of Judith Stein….
Update: Real reform still possible
Apparently the President will support use of the Senate “Reconciliation” process to move health care reform if the super-majority of 60 votes needed to avoid a filibuster can’t be garnered to pass a good plan. We heard this last week from a senior senator – he hoped a bipartisan vote would be possible, but indicated that certain principles need to be met by any health care bill, and that Reconciliation would be considered if those principles would otherwise be sacrificed. Amen to that.
Let’s not accept “something’s better than nothing” again! That mantra helped pass the 2003 law that gave us private Medicare Advantage, Part D, and windfalls for corporations – at the expense of Medicare participants and taxpayers. Been there, done that. This time we need a good plan with a solid public option that puts people above profits.
___
April 24th
CMA Health Policy Consultants’ contacts in DC indicate that a public option in health care reform is in jeopardy. Is it possible that after all the problems Medicare has had with private plans, and the plans’ exorbitant additional costs, that we will actually let corporate greed trump the interests of sick people and taxpayers once again?
CMA Health Policy Blog 