Archive for June 17, 2009

What’s Wrong With This Picture?

Congress Finds Tobacco Causes Serious Illness And Death. New England Journal Of Medicine Finds Health Insurance Industry Has Large Tobacco Stock Holdings.

The Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Act (H.R. 1256ENR) passed both houses of Congress and is awaiting the President’s signature. In that bill, Congress made the following findings:

  •  “Tobacco use is the foremost cause of premature death in America. It causes over 400,000 deaths in the United States each year, and approximately 8,600,000 Americans have chronic illnesses related to smoking.” H.R.1256 ENR §2(13)
  • “The use of tobacco products by the Nation’s children is a pediatric disease of considerable proportions that results in new generations of tobacco-dependent children and adults.” H.R.1256 ENR §2(1)
  • “A consensus exists that tobacco products are inherently dangerous and cause cancer, heart disease and other serious adverse health effects.” H.R.1256 ENR §2(2)
  • “Nicotine is an addictive drug.” H.R.1256ENR §2(3)
  • “Tobacco dependence is a chronic disease, one that typically requires repeated interventions to achieve long-term or permanent abstinence.” H.R. 1256 ENR §2(33)

So, why do health insurance companies, the very companies that Congress wants to run health care reform, have major holdings in tobacco companies?

A recent report in a letter to the New England Journal of Medicine (“Insurance-Industry Investments in Tobacco,” N Engl J Med 360:23, June 4, 2009, at 2483-2484) perhaps provides the answer:

“Insurance firms, like any business, are driven by profit and this fact compromises any health care plan that includes them…..Although investing in tobacco while selling life or health insurance may seem self-defeating, insurance firms have figured out ways to profit from both. Insurers exclude smokers from coverage, or more commonly, charge them higher premiums. Insurers profit … twice over.” (Id.)

According to this recent report, U.S. based Prudential Financial (which provides life and long-term disability insurance) owns tobacco holdings of $264.3 million; U.K. based Prudential (which provides health, life and long-term disability insurance) has a stake in tobacco totaling $1.38 billion; Standard Life (which offers health and life insurance) owns nearly $950 million of tobacco stock; Canada based Sun Life, which offers health, life, disability and long term care insurance owns just over $1 billion of tobacco stock. Northwest Mutual and MassMutual (both of which offer life, disability and long-term care insurance) respectively own more than $235 million and $585 million of tobacco stock. (Id.).

As the writers to the New England Journal of Medicine remarked, “[T]hese data are a reminder of the true priority of the insurance industry, which is making money, not ensuring health and well-being.” (Id.)

Are these really the companies we want running our new health care reform program?

June 17, 2009 at 7:55 pm Leave a comment

“Venting” About Single Payer Health Care

Dr. Walter Tsou, a former Commissioner of Health in Philadelphia and a public health physician, eloquently testified before Congress on Wednesday, June 10, 2009 about why a single payer health plan is necessary. Although the Washington Post saw fit to characterize his and other speakers’ thoughtful and reasonable opinions as “venting”, in fact Dr. Tsou made many excellent points. Among them were: 

  • The only affordable means to achieve quality health care for every American is through a “properly financed, single payer national health insurance program”;
  • Attempts to reconcile universal coverage with cost control are futile without a single payer plan;
  • Cost controls will mean that either taxpayers , physicians, hospitals or the private health insurance industry will have to ‘pay the piper’
  • The private health insurance industry, which has dominated health care for the past 50 years in a supposedly competitive marketplace, has proven unable to control costs, even while the quality of health care in the U.S. is “suboptimal” (the federal Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality’s term, not Dr. Tsou’s) and nearly 50 million people are uninsured
  • A single payer plan cuts costs by cutting insurance firms’ profits, streamlining the massive administrative apparatus that adds to the costs of hospitals and doctor’s offices, using bulk purchasing, negotiating fee schedules with physicians, and putting hospitals on predictable, global budgets
  • By entrusting health care to private health insurers, we have saddled the U.S. with an inefficient and exorbitantly expensive health care system that drives jobs overseas where health benefit costs are low, and discourages entrepreneurs from striking out on their own for fear of losing their health insurance coverage
  • The $19 billion dedicated to health information technology is doomed to failure because our health care system will remain too fragmented under any system but a single payer plan.

Medicare is a single payer system. It’s time that an “Improved and Enhanced Medicare for All” be seriously considered and adopted by Congress and President Obama. It is the best solution to our current health care mess.

The complete text of Dr. Tsou’s remarks can be found here.

June 17, 2009 at 3:22 pm 2 comments

Health Policy Expertise

We provide effective, innovative opportunities to impact federal Medicare and health care policies and legislation in order to advance fair access to Medicare and quality health care.

Judith A. Stein, Executive Director

Contact us by email
for a free consultation,
Or call at (202) 293-5760.
Se habla español
June 2009


%d bloggers like this: